Things I liked, Honestly the whole game was pretty fantastic. You had a ton of animations, the world was highly interactable and the menu system was even built into it! Your idea for the rewind theme was really well done with the tapes and while I did have some stuttering at the beginning it lowered pretty quickly.
Things I didn't like, this was as much of a pro as it was a con but the player is left to piece a tad few many things together. If you even just had a clipboard keeping track of when everyone said they entered the theater that would have helped. Ultimately not the worst thing as that makes the act of guessing correctly that much more satisfying.
Overall I really enjoyed your game and I can't wait to see what other mysteries you bake up for us in the future!
- Von Harley