I just played the game for half an hour, here are some criticisms / bug reports:
- GAME BREAKING bug: I used the character with red clothing and hat, the game crashes when a goblin mage does a debuff spell: ERROR: Failed to load: img/animations/StateDown1.png. My guess is you forgot to export the character's downed sprites.
- Controls are a bit weird, why have WASD for movement but still ZX for interacting? I think sticking to default arrow keys or just changing the interact buttons to JK or something would be better.
- Some NPCs you can't speak to, ex: the first ones you meet at the bar. (I know this isn't a bug, but consider adding more dialogue).
- I noticed a 'Steel Tongue Ring' in the shop and had no idea what it does, a short item description would help.
- Enemy encounters don't have battle backgrounds, RPG Maker has default ones and you use the default tileset already, just use those!
Here are a few things i did like:
- Music is good.
- Battles have an HP bar, it looks nice.
- Character customization, you don't see that very often.
Well, that's about it! If you fix the first game breaking bug I'll revisit this game and playtest it more. Cheers!