Idk how to describe it...but if the choice involves Hoss...do it. Personally, I got it first try, but just think about the relationship Hoss and Dave have with each other.
Ended up having to go through 7 times when i was trying to get it. My problem is i kept spending time with tyson and doing that at one point causes you to miss a conversation with hoss about his siblings and that stoped me from getting the affection up.