Glancing at the game as uploaded on itch, part of the issue is the wobble and tilt you've added. At 64x64px there simply isn't room for that. The other issue is that your textures aren't being applied in a pixel-perfect manner — look at the size of the clock's pixels vs the character/environment, or the goal-box pixels compared to the same.
I totally empathize. You've put a lot of work into this and it shows. Your environmental spritework is absolutely delightful. I'm sorry you've run into this at the end of the jam.
I can't tell you what to do about it. You'll have to listen to your heart on that one.
Viewing post in STEAL 'EM ALL jam comments
Honestly, I want to thank you all, but I don't have the time or the desire to redo everything in less than two days. If they want to kick me out of the jam, so be it. At least I had fun and got to experiment with these types of animations for the first time. I'll be able to reuse them in the future for other projects.