I'm a big fan of fairy tale retellings. This was an enjoyable retelling. You did a good job giving this an unsettling vibe. Even without making mistakes and Rumple showing up, it still had that horror feeling. Rumple showing up just added to that. The art and the sound worked really well for the feel you were going for.
It would have been nice if, instead of auto advancing, the player had to click something to go through the intro and ending. The first time I played, I was adjusting the zoom because I wasn't sure if the image was being cut off or not and missed some of the intro. It was easy to go through again, but it still would have been nice if I could have gone through the story at my own pace.
The gameplay took a bit to get use to. Sometimes it felt like I could get the wheel to stop moving, letting it sit at the space I needed. Other times, it felt like I had to be constantly taping on either Q or E to keep the wheel in the space I needed. Sometimes when I got the symbol correct, the wheel would spin to the other side, while other times it would stay on the symbol I had just gotten right. The differences didn't seem to be connected to the wheel modifiers, though the modifiers weren't always the easiest to see so they might have been. Once I got use to the fact that things didn't always feel consistent, it became easier to play.