Hii POY, the writing, art and audio is very cute and amazing, yet I'm still stuck this time...
On the good side, the evidences are all highlighted to find quickly, and the ordering is pretty obvious (said by Tori). But there is just not enough information to pick the right evidence and finish the deduction. (In the end I found the solution from comments)
- Beach + Weird Lump, the combination itself makes sense, but I think Paw Print should be considered correct too since they just come back from walk.
- Campsite + Tinfoil Mess, mhm, was thinking about using Weird Lump because this is where it's found, or Tarot Card for being witnessed by Charlie.
- Restaurant + Sunglasses, I don't see why it's related to restaurant from Grandma's words... no other evidences seem to pointing at restaurant area too.
- Toilets Area + Ripped Cloth, we can tell the ripped cloth belongs to Barney, but why it ends up in toilet...? I once put Weird Lump here lol.
- Beer Bottle shows Barney doesn't really drink, and it doesn't help on the deduction
So you see how confused I am... good job on the limitation I guess (¬ ω ¬)