fun game. i did not realize barking would force me to solve the puzzle. i was not prepared.
also the evidence is torn. bill fetch is definetly innocent and there isnt much evidence against amelia flouf. its really between holly and scraggy. both have the means to steal the bones. tracks of both were found at the crime scene. there is a connection between them so im starting to suspect it was both. the one with connections to them all however is...US. before i answer this i put out the theory that it was us. we are connected to them all, yet our character handwaves that away every time it comes up. we have the connections to be able to know about the stash.
ok so answering gives you more answers. like how was i supposed to know the scarf wasnt evidence. you need to give me that beforehand. also only some evidence isnt able to be presented. like hollys connection to scraggy and as such her access to the map wasnt an option. also the bone having a hole in it from something that didnt look like a bite mark i saw as evidence of research done on the bone. and so my nr.1 suspect went up in flames.
and then the game kinda ended. like im still not sure if scraggy did it. all that was revealed was that maybe he buried the stash. like what? the ending legit left me with more questions than answers.
what i think happened: fluffys grandpa made a mistake and thought scraggys stash was his. scraggy took the stash on his walk. fluffy, who thought from his grandpa that it was his stash thought someone had stolen from his stash, when it had never belonged to him in the first place.
all in all the game was fun. the ending kinda ruined it for me though. the evidence fuffy gives to discount evidence should have been available through other means. you literally have to guess the thief, as you are missing crucial information in the case. fluffy gives more evidence, than anything in the room. also the ending was so confusing i wasnt sure what had happened to the stash.