So "new guy" here is the representation of a regular goat and the others are meant to represent what the mutated goats look like, with a version for each of the four chaos gods? Then the goat in this story joins with the hopes of turning out like one of those mutated goats?
Aaw yeah, didn’t think it trough that much but yeah the “new guy” probably has seen mutated players before and wants to transform. Though I’d like to think that the “new guy” is special, the usual goats look like the guy on the left in the 7th pic. So the goats in the last pic would be how this specific goat would look like mutated.