hiiiii ^_^ i believe that actually the payment options depend on ur payout settings, currently its set to "direct collection" which only allows paypal :c if u switch to "collected by itch. o" (stripe) users like me can pay via credit card! :3 i rlly wanna support u and buy the dlc !! pls checkout what i said tysm <3
I'm already using "collected by itch.io, paid later" as my preferred payout method! ^^ And I prefer not to use "direct to you" as a payout option because of tax and liability issues. It's also why I always ask folks in the comment section to contact Itch support for refunds (since I literally don't have access to my earnings unless I initiate a payout akflgsa ^^;)
The "direct to you" option also offers Stripe payments if you connect your Stripe account (which I've already done), but because the DLC includes 18+ content, Itch has no choice but to remove Stripe as a payment processor. If anyone is interested in learning more, you can read about it in Itch's notice here, or in the FAQ mentioned on the Itch page.
And here's a TLDR screenshot for those who don't wanna read the entirety of Itch's notice sjgjhs:
