Post by bottomoftheocean in Whimsy Koi comments

Viewing post in Whimsy Koi comments

huge fan of this so far, but i have one note and one possible bug:

first, I think the fully grown koi might actually be too large - everything looks crowded and it's hard to appreciate how pretty each one actually is, especially when they're near the edge of the pond and get clipped off

second, the two 'sell all koi' buttons don't seem to work. they definitely did the other day, and I'm not sure if they're broken right now or if they don't work when you have locked fish. which would be odd, nearly every collector like this this that i've played would simply sell every fish that wasn't locked.

anyway, i look forward to the full release !

TingGame21 days ago(+1)

Thanks for playing and for the feedback!

I will definitely consider changing the koi size. It does look pretty busy when you have 30 adult koi.

The 'sell all' button issue sounds like a bug to me. It is supposed to sell all the fish except the locked ones. I will look into it to see what is wrong."

bottomoftheocean18 days ago

i've just noticed why it is that I thought the fish scale was too large - for some reason a couple of my fish have grown to 200%, and it's only those fish that seem particularly large. I had a few of them but sold them without thinking about it, but I do still have a robot koi. I'm not sure if they're supposed to continue growing?

bottomoftheocean18 days ago (1 edit)

this one, which is marked as a white and red koi even though it's actually purple, didn't stop eating and is now huge. I do have "not feeding adult koi" on

TingGame18 days ago (1 edit) (+1)

It’s definitely a bug. 🤣

I didn’t know that was even possible. I’ll try to fix it.

Does it still stay this big when you change the pond and then come back?

And does the number continue to go up when you click on it?

bottomoftheocean17 days ago

it did continue to get bigger and bigger, and i can't seem to recreate it with my current upgrades. it seemed to happen when a fish that was nearly grown would eat a lot of food all at once (like if i'd clicked a lot in one spot and it made a little pile). I'm not completely sure, but i think it did stay really big when i changed ponds. I'll try again to recreate it and see if i can figure out how it happened

TingGame17 days ago(+1)

I updated the game yesterday. The bug was likely caused because the game only checked for adult during natural growth, not when eating. I’ve added an extra check during feeding, so it should be fixed now.

Thank you for the feedback! Please let me know if you encounter it again.

bottomoftheocean15 days ago

back again lol, I haven't seen any overgrown fish since the update you mentioned, but the sell all buttons do seem to have an issue still. if there's no locked fish, it works perfectly - the sell all button sells all, and the sell adults button will sell all the adults and only the adults.

however, when there's locked fish in the pond, it seems to stop selling the fish when it hits one that's locked, instead of continuing checking the list of fish? if that makes sense? as in if the fish were in a list like this:

unlocked 1
unlocked 2
unlocked 3
locked 1
unlocked 4
unlocked 5
locked 2
locked 3
unlocked 6

it will sell the first three just fine, but not the other unlocked ones. if, however, i go through and unlock fish and try again, and happen to unlock "locked 1", it will then sell that fish, as well as unlocked 4 and 5. "unlocked 6" doesn't get sold though unless I unlock the remaining locked fish. I'm not sure if it's exiting a loop instead of just incrementing or something.

again though, I'm a huge fan and I'm looking forward to a full release !

TingGame13 days ago(+1)

Thanks for the feedback! I’ve fixed the locked Koi bug, so it should work properly now.

itch.io

Viewing post in Whimsy Koi comments