What issue?
Scroll down further. Your game even appears in the suggestion box, when you type. Also in tags. If you use the horror tags, there are many games in there that are also popular.
And bad publicity is still publicity. If they deleted fake ratings your game's apparant popularity might have been newly calculated and was adjusted. If they newly calculate such things, it might also take a while till the averages are correct again. I have no clue how they do it. But I do know that they do not simply count views and that the ranking is not straightforward. There even is a bonus for new games that skews ranking.
The game is still on page 1 here https://itch.io/games/last-7-days