Yeah, you only have four chances fo stuff her so failing one night (either by getting caught or not gettinf enough ingredients) essentially reduces her maximum size for the run and affects the endings.
So Night 1 was the ony time you stuffed her, and you made it to the cooking scene in Night 4 before she got ya? If I have all that right then that really helps to narrow down the event that I need to look at. Thanks again for the heads up!