To be completely honest, i think the game will find it's players and right people itself. I think we turn people off by making these huge statements with sighs, three dots, ATTENTION NEW PLAYERS, leave a like to support the game, trying to prove to a random person who just looked at the game why it's not similar to Baldi's Basics with 35 sentences, e.t.c. The discord channel #ask-youtubers where we tried to show this game again to markiplier. Like, why would you want to introduce new potential players in the game with
"Sigh...Here we go."
All of these things leave a bad atmosphere to the game to the outsiders, it makes us look like the fanbase to sonic.exe.
Please understand i am not making fun of anybody and not trying to insult anyone. I am just trying to help the game. What i recommend is to just focus completely on the game, and it will find it's players in the meantime :) Trying to promote it to fans of other games is like sub4sub on YouTube, it doesn't work or make anything better.