Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(2 edits) (+1)(-11)

Can someone explain how and why an ethnic slur (pinda) was picked as the name of one of the main characters? The dog being named after a Dutch brand of chocolate milk clearly sets the language domain, leaving little to no room for alternative interpretations.

(+2)(-1)

...

(+5)(-2)

your wiktionary link says "pinda" means "peanut"

(+1)(-6)

That is sense 1, yes, the literal meaning. When applied to a person however, it is exclusively interpreted in the 4th sense. Look harder. Saying it's not a slur because it means peanut is like saying spade isn't a slur because it means shovel.

"Sense 4 is from the pejorative term pindachinees from the 1930s, which was later applied even more pejoratively to people from East Asia in general, including Indonesians who came en masse to the Netherlands in the late 1940s.

[...]

4. (derogatory, ethnic slur) people from East Asia, most commonly Chinese and Indonesians"

(-1)

When applied to a person however, it is exclusively interpreted in the 4th sense

It just a name.

Saying it’s not a slur because it means peanut is like saying spade isn’t a slur because it means shovel

It depends on context.

(4 edits)
It just a name.

You wouldn't say that about any slur you're familiar with, I hope.

It depends on context.

Well, exactly... with the context being either object or person.

(1 edit)

You wouldn’t say that about any slur you’re familiar with

I can imagine a kid named Nerus (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D0%BD%D0%B5%D1%80%D1%83%D1%81%D1%8C ) or Moskal (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D0%BC%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BB%D1%8C#Ukrainian ), for example, and see no problem here because it’s just a name.

Do you self-identify as racist?

(1 edit)

Can someone explain how and why an ethnic slur (pinda) was picked as the name of one of the main characters?

There are 4 meanings of this word, according to Wiktionary, and 1 of them related to chocolate.

No, none relate to chocolate, and 3 of the 4 meanings are effectively the same, since they all refer to the plant or part of it.

No, none relate to chocolate

Sorry, my bad.

and 3 of the 4 meanings are effectively the same, since they all refer to the plant or part of it

But You still thinks that it’s a slur.

Obviously, those 3 senses are not. 🤦

those 3 senses are not

So why You chose only 1 offensive meaning of the word?

(1 edit)

That meaning was chosen because it is the only one referring to a person, not because it is offensive. It being offensive was the motivation for the OP... after first sending an email to the Godot Foundation and pointing it out in the FreeGameDev chat.

(-1)

That meaning was chosen because it is the only one referring to a person, not because it is offensive

I see here a deliberate choice of only one meaning that suits You (especially considering the dog’s name, which is the name of a brand of chocolate milk).

It being offensive was the motivation for the OP… after first sending an email to the Godot Foundation

And what does the Godot Foundation have to do with it? Judging by the game’s website, DOGWALK has nothing to do with them.

P.S. - Thanks to Google Translate for helping with the answer.

Try DeepL.