does anyone have like a list about type of monsters you should use and not use for potions? I sometimes forget which is which
eyeball:no boob potion but still fine with milk potion
skeleton: no butt potion but fine with thigh potion
zombie:no dumb potion (yellow potion) but fine with horny potion
knight:no thigh potion but fine with butt potion
slime: fine with any potion
vampire: hates every potion
mimic: fine with any potion but needs dizzy potion with other potions
(every monster likes and doesn't like potions)
Some corrections: Its perfectly fine to use potions on those who the scroll shows will visit the vampire, unless the Vampire specifically says "don't feed potions to vampire hunters".
Similarly, the Kraken also appears on the scroll as part of its questline, and there's no specific potion exclusions for him.
Also, I don't believe the mimic appears on the scroll, and a more accurate description of its rule would be "Only give the mimic treasure map to those who would already be getting the Dizzy potion." Giving a Dizzy potion just to give the mimic map is invalid.