[I share my rating publicly, because i feel like that's more fair for you and me]
I like the animations. Now the progress is wayy too slow (for me). I'm sure you played with the assistant, but here its not available. I think making the core loop more rewarding would help a ton, adding variety too (like the golden cookie from cookie clicker, something random that makes you change the objective for a short time)
Gameplay: 2 stars
Theme: 1 star → I did not see any mention of microtransaction, but maybe i left the game too early
Polish: 3 star → I like it, even though the animations and overall balance is very slow (easy fix though)
Visuals & Audio: 2 stars → It's visually coherent, and the audio has so much untapped potential
Overall i think these are all easy fixes, i suggest looking at a game that's very similar and take note of everything that makes progress feel rewarding and not repetitive (my little universe for example)
Don't hesitate to ask if you have any questions !