Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

Constructive criticism time! (Beware of SPOILERS beyond the 1st paragraph.)
Also I apologize in advance for the wall of text.
Opinions about the build and story at the bottom.

I do like different line transitions, and when the author of a VN plays with the text, but one of the effects added in the 2nd build were in my opinion used too frequently in the latest build. Specifically the text sliding in. 
It was in my opinion used too often for it to have an impact when used in later instances in the build. Though that could simply be due to misplaced expectations due to how rare other text-effects have been used so far. 

Another critique I have is that some of the information leading to the outburst felt too sudden. To clarify: I'm not critiquing the outburst itself - as it seems to be written to set some expectations about the MC's mental state going forward. I'm talking about the reveal during the shopping, that ultimately led to it. 
I'm going to reference one of my all time favorite authors here, on how he does these reveals in a way that both foreshadows it, yet hides it till the "reveal": Brandon Sanderson. One thing he excels at is giving information that is the cornerstone for a later reveal or twist, distracts the reader with everything else going on, then later reveals the twist built on that information. Making the reveal a moment of "I should have seen that coming, but I didn't!"

One minimalistic way this could be applied to this case (though I'm no author, and your artistic vision trumps anything any of us say, so feel free to ignore this bit):
-SPOILER-

- Reveal the information about the MC's salary early (somewhere within build 1's content). But not the context. Aka, the amount or standard, but not how much that covers in his new home. Perhaps even a line stating that it's a very decent, perhaps even good salary (on Titan). Maybe better than what he had to live off before.

The rest of the information revealed in that part of the build I feel don't necessarily need more foreshadowing, as they are tied to that little piece of information, and his mental state.

----

Now for my opinions on this build (and the story so far):
I'm so far really enjoying this story. Since it's very early in development I'm assuming there will be more sprites for minor NPCs arriving as this game develops?
The improved background for the dorm room is very much appreciated, especially now that it has two beds. 
One thing that kept pleasantly surprising me throughout the build was the length. I've played too many ongoing VNs, so I was expecting the build to end at several spots, just for it to oh so joyously continue. 
-SPOILER-

I didn't suspect that the MC and Kai's relationship would go the way it did as fast as it did, and I personally like it. Though I must say, the club scene gave me some serious second hand embarrassment.

(+1)

thanks so much for the feedback, I appreciate it! I was actually considering going back into build one and adding some introspection about the MC being happy that he's atleast getting paid for it... even if he'd rather just be home. Im still happy to go back and follow through with that idea, but adding content into a build one during a build 3, not many people will go back and read that... even then, it's still worth it to do so. The text effects are used only during high emotional scenes/ horror scenes,  and this build is highly emotional and horrifying haha. When you counteract it with the pace of build three, it will feel more normal I believe.


As for the outburst, yeah I've mentioned before it has 0 to do with money or finances, it's about eco realizing that he cant escape his people's past. His over the top reaction is meant to lend itself to his mental condition... other vns have a character that sees their friends and the world go insane around them... my vn is the opposite. You're going insane and everyone else around you is normal (hence the glitched kai sprites). Obviously if the MC only had an over the top reaction only during expected and reasonable times... then he'd be an expectant and reasonable character, which he was never meant to be.


Yes, more sprites are added in for every build! Build 3 will include vulterus and kezza.


Kai and eco's relationship will make a lot more sense in build 3 :)

(+1)

Thank you so much again for taking the time to comment <3