It seems like you didn’t fight Gemma yet. If you visit the tavern a few times in the daytime an event will eventually proc starting the quest. There is a lot more planned but I think everything in the journal goals list should be possible to unlock, though a lot of the sex progression stuff is intended to be stuff you unlock over an entire playthrough, so I don’t necessarily recommend grinding it all out.
Viewing post in Hex: Becoming a Succubus comments
I was only doing sex skills because I wasn't sure what else there was to do. I thought, as the main character is a succubus it might unlock more of the story that way. Now that I know there's a bit more to do than that right now, will try visiting the tavern and triggering that new stuff. I know I forgot to say this before (got caught up in everything else so sorry about that) but thanks for getting back to me and answering all those questions. Not all devs get this involved with the people that leave reviews so it's very refreshing and definitely appreciated :)