Thank you for your honest and exhaustive review. We gave you a game. Turns out it's not what you want. I feel like I've stolen you time though, and in hope of making it up to you, I offer you this puzzle game: https://bodro.itch.io/klss
KlSS was made in 2 or 3 weeks (instead of 48 hours) and is more traditional (it eventually ends).
For "Not What I Want", we already have a fixed build, but can't upload it until the end of the rating process.
'Turns out it's not what you want' *rimshot*
I'll probably give it another shot once the fixed build is out, but the Kiss game looks cool. Reminds me of Adventure (which I assume was the aim).
In regards to the 'AAA' comment made by the other dev; I look at all games - jam or no - as I would a 'finished' title. I do try to cut some slack if some stuff is obviously not finished, but I do tend to be a bit harsh about certain game breaking bugs or certain cut corners. I try to respect ideas, implementation, and effort! The idea of a puzzle game where you try to guess what someone wants has been done before and is good, though I assume that wasn't your full goal. As for implementation...well, you have my review. As for effort, it was a game jam to be sure, and y'all are pushing out an update with a few fixes so that's great! And obviously you went through the trouble of the video and the changing furniture and rooms and whatnot.
Keep on keeping on!
