Haven't played, but thank you for writing this retrospective treatise.
(I don't normally play games, so your detailed account of your experiences, whys and wherefores were great for me to hear)
Not the original poster but I want to say I enjoy reading postmortems like this and would actively look for them (even for games I don’t actually play). I think it’s both informative and entertaining.
I definitely enjoy your thought process in this one, although I must say my eyes are truly bleeding at thin black on purple.