The puzzles were unclear, even for a point and click game, and the almost complete lack of sound was jarring. It was really unclear what could and couldn't be interacted with, but I pressed on because the story intrigued me...

Annnd then that never really wrapped up in a satisfying way. There were so many dangling threads. Why were people disappearing? Where did they go? What's with the church? The morse code? The person we saw in the hall towards the beginning of the game?

The supernatural events just felt like spooky things happening for the sake of being spooky, and then it ended with "UHHHHH EYEBALL MONSTER YEAH".