Pros:
The game is a promising hybrid of action rpg and sex game. I really like that its reality has some more level instead of just this is Jon McFuckton defending Cumville with his cock.

The pets are a really nice gimmick, hope you add more in the future. I kinda wish we could see a flying bird pet that the player can use to cross distances faster by skipping the map obstacles.

Cons:
Severe lack of bearded dudes. I mean, I know this sounds niche but come on, especially with the bearskin dude, I expected him to keep his beard for the sex scene. I was all excited to see him reward the player like a horny caveman in heat, then "weeeell, I shaved :DDDD" also Johannes is a weird case, not just because he ends up losing his beard at the end of the sex scene (are you implying that part of the curse's hideousness was having a beard??? lol) it is also the fact that as the player, I cannot shag him. He was the hottest of the characters, and it felt like a shame to see it would be just the player and his hand in the end. I know that the game doesn't need to be 100% player-centered, but damn man, at first you cockblocked me and then you used magical shave on him.

The grinding can be tedious. By grinding I mean finding the upgrade items for the pets in the ends of the dungeons and the hp max upgrades. I don't mind having to try a little bit more, it is just that there is a lot of just going up and down in the map and the player doesn't have a run function, not to mention that the foxholes aren't that plenty either.
I have thought of the following; what if at the end of the dungeons, instead of just being a chest with a random ass carrot, there is a boss fight that ends with you fucking with the boss? The boss could be either some hunky sorcerer, some magical creature, or anything else you'd like. It would just help making the grinding part of the game feel more fulfilling instead of run here, use skill, dodge, dodge, open chest.


Some additional suggestions:
1) Give the toggle to have men be bearded or shaved, including the player and his brother.
2) Add some faster movement functions so that trekking the map is more comfortable and less of a chore.
3) Add some sexual elements to combat, like the ability to seduce monsters and have sex with them in the overworld.
4) Maybe add the ability for the main character to jerk off? It would be kinda hot to be able to direct him to blow of some steam. Maybe you could pair this with the romanceable guys and make it some short of feature where you could visit them at certain times and either have sex with them or jerk off together with them, or perhaps even have threesomes and orgies.
5) Implement some day/night cycle where the npc behavior changes depending on the hour. At day, people are more active and go around doing business. At night, they stay in or go to taverns, and some choose to end the day by taking care of their pent up need to fuck; some npcs jerk off late at night when alone, and some are having sex either in private or in public (e.g. orgy in the pub) and the best thing is that the player can catch them and hopefully even join them (would love to be given the chance to sleep over at the guardian's house then have an event trigger where the player wakes up in the middle of the night and catches the guardian beating his meat for example)
6) Have the player's sprite change depending on the armor he is wearing.

All in all, I think this is a game with potential, but some things drag the quality down unnecessarily. Still I understand that this is just an early build, and I can't wait to see what you will do with this project. Keep up the good work :)