itch.io

Sorry, can't really remember what happened prior to those bugs I reported except that it was the browser version.
I'm on a different computer right now and the music not resuming after the pause isn't happening.

For WASD controls, which buttons do you think would work best for punching and jumping?

I use WASD and JKL for 2D games like these.

frame limit / vsync option please!

I like how the general look and the models.
The blood seems a bit exaggerated considering that enemies explode when you kill them with a pistol but I like the effect, in some rooms it gets on the ceiling and it looks like it's floating in mid-air.

I immediately went to check the lockers and then I thought I got stuck in them. In reality my inputs were disabled because of the dialogue but the dialogue UI immediately hides if the character is touching a wall, happens with the opposite wall too. A couple of times the flamethrower ammo failed to appear in my inventory on pickup but I can't replicate it reliably. 

Cool start, I'm looking forward to see what proper combat plays like.
The sawblade gun sucks btw it's a worse shotgun. 

Lots of small audio bugs: music not restarting when unpausing or punch sounds disappearing after a while, desynched enemy attack sound when they're attacking the floor.

One time the game got stuck on level 4 and never went to level 5:

Got repeatedly filtered by wave 15.

The brick area you hit when punching from below doesn't seem to be consistent: sometimes you will jump at a crab and the blue bricks are much smaller and you'll nudge the crab forward instead of stunning it which is very annoying because that crab goes from ammo to problem. idk if it's supposed to be a mechanic and I didn't get it.

Rebindable keys would be great I usually play these kind of games moving with WASD and doing the rest with my right hand.

Sometimes enemies spawn from the side of the screen instead of doing the normal drop thing.
Sometimes hitting the enemies with an upward punch changes their direction. I think this is intended but occasionally it doesn't work, although it might be some wonky physics where the enemy is technically changing direction but is in mid-air except too close to the wall to fall until the knockback from the upward punch has ended.

I wish punching kept a smidge of momentum instead of stopping you completely.

Lots of fun overall.

I like how it looks, it's very charming.

I was trying to get my dudes to build a 8x5 wooden house but they were taking forever and I couldn't figure out how to reassign them to build the basic cooking station first so I tried quitting to menu and that didn't work so I quit to desktop and now when I open the game again the buttons don't do anything, which is a first. 
This persisted after deleting the folder and a reboot, alt-entering the game to force it to run in windowed mode doesn't help either. Does your game save anything externally?

Anyways my only real feedback for now is that I wish you could queue tasks the sims style and that the UI showed you the character's needs without needing to individually check each one to find which of them is starving. 

I could buff the player's baseline alchemy stats and nerf the tank upgrades? Do you think that would alleviate the issue?

I feel like something as crucial as the tank capacity upgrade is always going to be too useful to ever skip. It's the only thing that helps when fighting many enemies of the same type.

The only way I could see myself not saving for it first is if weapons had more upgrades that helped with stock consumption, but then I'd save for those instead, kicking the can down the road.
It feels like a similar situation to that build before you added cauldrons where tier 2 elements were an upgrade so I always got that one first, that's why I think getting tank upgrades from bosses or in the store would be better. 
But if you want to keep them as an upgrade then yeah making the baseline better could make the alchemy upgrades feel like training wheels for new players? Like a safety net that's good to have but good players can play without, maybe.

Neat.
Could use a "press tab to view manual" at the start and a slider for mouse sensitivity.
Got the bad ending first and the good ending second after I realized that there's a symbol above the opponent's blast door. I was disappointed that you can't see the fight but I get that it would have been a lot of work.
I think the game would have been creepier if you were actually working on a creature instead of a metal thing. Like a fetus sort of creature that rises like dough in the microwave and then screams when you put it in the heat/cold/electricity machine or something like that.

Bugs I found:

The computer UI should just be a fixed size instead of a 3D object you can walk into. If you are too close to a wall you can't click on the manual. The L-M-I meat patties things vibrate on their dispenser, the module you need to microwave clips through the tube chamber floor and softlocks you.

Very nice, finished the hardest difficulty with a pet build:

Pets are so much more convenient than weapons since you don't need to also buy the movement modules to make them function. Wireless Wireworks.
I wish the demo was longer, maybe even have an endless mode to see how strong a build can get. 

Had fun.

Hey I recognize those ammo sprites!

I'm not much into the idea of a time trial target thing as opposed to, for example, a sidescroller with actual enemies.
It feels like it'd get repetitive fast especially if there's no time limit and you can clear levels by taking your time.

Great job with the juice, the weapons and sound effects are punchy.
The arsenal seems good enough for what you're trying to do, the shotgun doesn't seem to really have a place I'd make it have some knockback so it doubles as a mobility tool, TF2 force-a-nature style. It's a fun trope I even added that in my game. 

The only thing I don't like about the movement is that you can't fire up or down when sliding on a wall: it's easy to accidentally snap to it when trying to hit a target that's above you. 
It also might be nice if holding down while mid-air gave you downward velocity, it could be used to get on downward slopes faster or just better air control depending on how tricky you intend to make the level. 

Cool start though, I'll check this out again next time.

Sorry to hear you got stuck.

The normal way to proceed is through the other side of the canyon where there's a cave entrance covered by grass.
But you can also skip the cave by jump over the canyon with a shotgun jump or a grenade jump if you've found the grenade launcher. 

Are there enemies that can ride along your boat?

Yes the eeldogs (4 legged monsters) can jump on your boat. Fishes can also do that and they'll eventually die. 

Thanks for the feedback, I'll be more mindful of things like that in the future.

Very generous with crystals this time around and I finished the whole thing without a single combat upgrade thanks to the turret power. I felt that combat upgrades are like a tax that you have to pay, it's annoying to waste your hard earned mineral on something that's a token "get this so you don't die" upgrade. Even with the new enemies combat feels like a token phase that interrupts your mining. Personally, since you've already implemented mouse control, I'd make it so the lil dude can walk around and shoot guns. You could even make it so there's random guns to find around so exploration would reward combat without sacrificing progression. Whatever way you choose to tackle it I think combat is the weakest part right now.

The final sequence was cool and looking for objective around the map was nice.

This thing stole my minerals and doesn't seem like it did anything.

The extra vision was a nice buff to get but the camera being zoomed out caused a jittering effect which was annoying.
Having these little side things is a fun shakeup from the monotone mineral mining, good addition.

Very charming look, I like it a lot.

It took me a minute to realize that you're supposed to bring loot back to the mimic, but it's a boring to backtrack for individual pieces of loot that you have to hold with both hands like the silver pitcher. There's an exploit where you can move the sack by running into it which lets you carry more loot around and it's faster.
Trying to get specific items is a pain especially from a pile but also like singular coins have a very narrow angle from which you can grab them.
I also thought the camera was annoying, specifically it's hard to read what the farmers are saying because they are so much taller.

This guy got stuck there making his talking noises over and over. It got unstuck when I walked close.
After the goat got me once it broke and couldn't aggro to me anymore. 
There's a ring in the goat's chest that I can move but can't pickup. 
I wonder what the little toad next to the goat is for, looks like it would trigger an eater egg if brought something. 

Cool game overall I want to play more of it. 

Fire trial is much easier, I think you might have disabled the other trials for testing and forgot about it because I only found fire trials in like 4 runs.
This guy got spawned outside the map by one of those boss turned regular enemy in floor 3:

Good twist by the way, it works well as a regular enemy.

I entered a boss chamber on floor 3 and it got filled to the brim with floating orbs, thankfully the virulent update plus steam is great at thinning hordes like that. Virulent update + fire trial buff also caused some fun chain reactions that cleared whole rooms.

The new boss was good. I found it easy enough to keep track of both of them and I thought it was neat how they can damage each other.

Whenever I get set on fire I usually do water + health but if I do that with the barrier upgrade I get neither water nor health and I die. 

I think maybe the chem tank upgrades should be given in some other ways because they feel mandatory to get first.

It was fun to finish again.

Hey thanks for checking the game again. 

Because I think the only really crucial thing to replace now would maybe be the GUI

I think I'll leave all UI stuff for last, gotta settle on its final design before making it look good

As for the player and the enemies, you could use some momentum

The player does have a little bit of friction/momentum when moving, but it's not really noticeable unless you're in the air. 
I'll see if the game feels better with it. 

Do pickups retain whatever you don’t need?

Everything except the crates and weapons you already have.

That dark shaman should really make some sort of noise when he teleports

He should be doing that but I noticed that certain sound effects don't play properly sometimes, or maybe in your case it was just buried behind other sounds, not sure. I'll investigate it.  

and it causes the performance to get a bit spotty on my old rig

Yeah performance has been a pain especially considering how simple the game's visuals are. It's mostly enemy physics causing framedrop issues from what I've seen, I'm going to try and see if I can simplify some things and make it better. 

Also having his attacks be both hitscan and AOE that hits you through walls is especially annoying

I will add a check so that explosion doesn't damage the player through walls. Technically the explosion is not hitscan: it spawns on the particle effect so it's possible to fling yourself away before it hits you using a grenade jump or a shotgun jump but the timing is too precise so I don't think any player will organically discover that trick. 

I really don’t like how it doesn’t remember which weapon variant you were last using when you hit the number keys, the trenchgun is way more situationally useful than the coachgun and it’s a pain having to switch a second time.

Good point, I'll change that. 

Ended up stopping after the first level

It's okay there really isn't anything new since last demo day past the first level aside from like the music.

Thanks for playing again! I do think that there's something off about the game, might be the movement system like you said but I think combat is too shallow. Things die too quickly and enemies don't really do much beside running at you. Or maybe I played too much of it and I'm seeing problems that aren't there. 
Either way, Thanks for the feedback. Always appreciated. 

Tom Sawyer is my win condition. 

I think the new UI is a good idea overall, a bit dispersive since the show is now encircling the board but maybe it's better than switching through tabs.
Buzzwords are a cool idea but I skipped the tutorial and didn't know what they were until I read your post. 
There could be a tooltip when hovering over them that tells you what they are.

I still think a log telling you how a particular score was achieved and a word validator checker would go a long way, it sucks to work towards a big word and have it ruined because it turns out that it isn't a word. 

Other bug I found: 
This bought "IN" is staying on the board even when I remove it, it's not game breaking, I can move it and it will be considered placed but if I click it or right click it stays there with a shadow below it. I have the +1 hand size perk if it matters.

By the way this game needs the ability to see the board once the game is over and also a log to see what triggered what:
at the end of this game I used the backwards spelling perk to spell "DENS" and it turns out "SNED" is also a word so both counted and both were vertical and both retriggered so I unexpectedly completed the final round in a single turn by placing down 2 tiles, it would be cool to see the math/reason behind how many points you get.

Hey thanks for trying the game out again. 

I think ammo might be a bit too generous right now, since I never really worried about it unlike my previous attempt

Yeah I've erred on the side of caution this time. Balancing for both the players that explore and those who don't will be hard. I should probably make them scale with the newly added difficulty option.

but his jump slam attack seems to trigger even when he lands on objects that aren't the ground

Didn't consider that. I should be able to make it so he breaks the sandbags when landing on them without triggering the slam that oughta fix it. 

Thanks again for the feedback!

Caliber Fortuna got renamed? 

Not a long demo but what's here is pretty good. 
Nitpicks/suggestions:
I don't like how much recoil all the guns have, you're not really aiming at anything as much as towards the enemies. I also wish your own weapons switched to ADS faster when using bullet time. 
This seems like the kind of game that could benefit from sliding or sprinting around like in F.E.A.R.
Let me detonate demo charges by shooting at them.
It would be cool if dash always smashed through walls. By the way I did the whole level on hard without realizing that you can gib people by dashing into them. Very fun mechanic.

My favorite gun was the heavy pistol, good damage and decent handling unlike the carbine ungodly recoil. Best sights too.

Fun demo, I'm looking forward to playing more. 

Writing down feedback as I play:

The game opening with a loud baseball bat noise before the player can adjust volume is good, good games always deafen players and send them scrambling for the option menu. It asserts dominance.

I expected the tone to be more lighthearted considering that the game is about a kid killing green dudes with a slingshot.

I'd like to be able to hold the fire button to fire the slingshot continuously considering that the slingshot has infinite ammo.

Tried a controller just to see if it played better but the reticle is much easier to aim with a mouse, usually in twinstick shooters you rotate the character in a general direction instead of moving a reticle. 

Let me quit the arcade minigame without having to die 3 times please.

The character moving off-center feels bad, I think it would work better if the camera became offset from the center instead so you didn't move closer to the edge of the screen when you move. 

Sometimes the hurt noise is pitched up to presumably sound like a kid but sometimes it isn't and it sounds like an adult, seems unintended.
The pistol sounds like it's being fired underwater in another room.
The bloody footprint effect is nice, I only just noticed it. 
The suburb level being a square you can roam around is dispersive, maybe when there's 10 or so enemies remaining you could have an arrow pointing at the closest one. 
1 and 2 being previous and next weapon is unorthodox for keyboard controls, I'd rather have each number key select a gun, guess I'll stick to the mouse wheel to select different ones.

City part, I was searching for the last 2 enemies for 5 minutes so I decided to check if you can fall in those holes.
You can fall in those holes. 

I used a grenade and picked up a molotov and now I can't pickup grenades. I think there's a limit on grenades in general instead of by types. Some UI indication would be good also regular grenades have are very hard to time right because of their long fuse.

The blood effect looks bad because it has a cooldown. I think you have a single particle in the enemy scene that is set to emit when hit which means there can only be one active at a time, a better solution would be to pool more than one or instantiate them as needed. It sounds like a small thing but it does a lot for weapon feedback.

School level, I like it more than wandering around looking for kills. 
The fence here does not extend all the way down and I went out of bounds: 

Even going out of bounds I couldn't find the last enemy.
Boss got stunlocked by the m16 for most of the fight then I shot it a bunch with the shotgun and it died, not super interesting. 
Was the last enemy the boss? I've been conditioned to clear levels and ignore area transitions so I thought the counter was broken.

I think enemies need to be a bit more interesting, I never needed to dodge and I barely needed to sprint. 
The dog enemy could have a lunge attack for example that require you to dodge out of the way instead of being able to backpedal away from it. 
I'm not a fan of the two city levels being so open and dispersive, I'd rather the levels be a bit more linear and have properly planned encounters, the levels being less open would also make it harder to backpedal away from everything. 
There is a lot of ammo and it didn't feel like guns did anything much different from each other. There's no real reason not to use the shotgun or assault rifle for everything. I think a reload mechanic could add some ebb and flow to combat, right now you just kinda walk backwards while firing at everything. 

The style is charming but I still have whiplash from the kid's parents getting butchered and then seeing those silly little goblinoids taking a car for a joyride.

I don't clear slots after all the items have been used on purpose, so you don't have to reassign them if you find new ones.

Right, that makes sense. Maybe food items or duplicate weapons could have a flag that doesn't slot them in the hotbar automatically, or all food could be pooled into a single slot to reduce clutter. 

Scatterbrained feedback:
A master option for the volume would be nice. 
Can't click the slide bar in the hotkey menu and the list doesn't scroll properly when I use the arrow key to navigate it. 
Enemies get stuck on chests and traps, they have trouble navigating around the library room.

^doomcaller stuck on traps

Items stay on the hot bar even after using them all. Is there a way to rearrange them? 
Enemy status effect should show up on their health bar
Fire shield description says "lasts _ seconds" 

I killed the boss, did a couple of floors and then got bored so I started running past enemies, I think that part is endless?
I don't like melee combat in this game. The power bar is glacial and it takes too long to reach the red part so it throws away your timing. 
Also it's hard to gauge weapon reach by eye and holding S plus sprint while timing a strike over and over is not that fun. 
Could use some dodge/stun/block/push mechanics to be more interesting. 
I picked up a fire book from the initial chest and never used anything else. Mana replenishing automatically means that it's viable to use as your only weapon.
My suggestion would be to balance around (an improved version of) melee combat and leave the spells as buffs/debuffs or a limited pool otherwise everyone is going to use nothing but spells considering that they're so much safer and more effective. 
The dungeon itself gets boring quickly, the only cool thing that happened was finding a secret in a library but even that gave me like 10 apples and nothing else. 
Visuals are not great, not talking about the enemy sprites but the dungeon itself: it's so blurry, repetitive and evenly lit, it's an eye sore.

I think you should re-evaluate the core melee combat mechanic and find ways to make dungeon rooms more exciting. I don't mind the billboarding sprite but I think they're only justified if you have a ton of enemies, people will expect either 3D models or more detailed and properly lit sprites. 

The game starts without mouse capture so when I saw the turret moving on its own I thought it was following the cursor while I was using the gamepad, turns out the tank auto aims which is always lame. 

I like the models I think you did a good job there. 

Some thoughts on each phase: 
I prefer moving tanks with the D-pad (or keys) because they are able to pivot on the spot. 
Your tank struggles with this, it looks like its rotation rate is linearly dependent on its speed, maybe it could have some higher minimum value for pivoting. It also keeps moving forward or backward if you hold A or D.
Gameplay-wise you're moving around and spamming sluggish auto-aimed shots, not very interesting. 

The helicopter controls fine, I prefer when helicopters have a throttle since that lets you do tighter turns.

The plane physics are really forgiving, you can slow up so much that it basically hovers on the spot. Still, timing strafes and avoiding missiles was more fun than the "throw off the enemy aim and hold the fire button" gameplay of the other phases imo. Tanks are a menace even when you're flying at max speed which is funny. 

It was neat. Not having to aim and the overly simple controls didn't grip me but that's personal preference. 

Thanks for playing and for the feedback!

I'll make the main character taller and eventually I'll have to rework both the mutant and dog enemies, they're too simple and wooden at the moment. 

Almost suspected the glass floor/wall to be destroyed and cause a new phase.

Good guess. It was meant to be a non-functional elevator just to hint that there was a way to get to that floor before the crane opened a hole to the side, but I never got around modeling it so for now it's just random glass in the middle of the room.

Mutation wise though, I feel like it's too many options to choose from, would rather have 3-5 instead of all 15. They also don't seem quite balanced, some seem much better than others

Yeah, I added the new ones a couple of hours before DD so they haven't been tested very much for balance. Stacking all the ones that make you slow is miserable, for example. The mutation system is due for a rework as well, I agree that giving a bunch of options to the player all at once is not interesting. Needs some limitations and unlocks. 

Game felt overall fun, story felt cheesy but enough context for what we're doing. Seems to be on track for me, but always room for improvement.

Thanks again, I'll do my best and I'll keep working hard. 

Fun! The setting is cool and I love the fast combat.
Mechs and grapple hooks is a combination made in heaven.

I manage to die in the first arena and when I respawned the character was stuck and I had to go back to the main menu and start the level again through debug. Second try I don't know how after some combat I ended up back the start of the level and I couldn't progress. Tested the other levels through debug.

Up and down can be disorienting but that mostly because of the uniform metal corridors not making it obvious.
Physics is really smooth I like that. Sometimes the camera clips through walls. 
Cool music too. 

Hope to play more of this. 
Vsync and FPS limit options would be appreciated. 

but wouldn't that simplify things too much?

The chain itself is fine it's just that my brain sees blue and thinks "fire" and then it sees icy white and thinks "fire" and then it sees neutral white and things "fire?" and only one of this is correct and it always throws me off when I see a bunch of blue, white and cyan circles next to each other. Countering blue with purple is not as immediate as countering red with blue. Maybe electricity should be yellow?
Please note that it's just my tired brain playing a hard game's hard mode after a long day, it's probably not that big of a deal if a player is paying attention and has a fresh brain.

I could make it so self-inflicted statuses don't trigger the barrier, but I'm not a fan of breaking generality like this.

Applying fire to myself would have resulted in me having no status effect so it felt unintended but if it's working correctly then I see no issue with it, it's just a quirk of the effect that the player can work around if needed.

I could highlight the player's current recipes in a dedicated UI gizmo

My first instinct was to check the almanac, maybe that can have an indicator of what you can currently make. Like a lock icon or something.

Fun! But not too much to say since it's so short. 
Only issue I found was that if you go back to the previous area enemies don't reset when you come back so they can hit you while the screen transition is happening. 

Hope to play more of this. 

Scatterbrained feedback as I play:

Still controls like you're walking on ice. Do you need to decelerate so slowly? 
I prefer putt mode to shooting. It's more precise and easier to predict. The aim line in putt-mode is slightly misaligned from the center of the ball.
You can enter putt mode while the ball is still moving and it'll roll away. Seems unintended.
Saving only saves what floor you're in and not your in-floor progress? I saved before entering the third floor and found myself back having to do the second one. I guess next time I'll only save if I'm down to the last ball? imo just get rid of this save system and give the player checkpoints, nobody wants to do the same minigolf courses over and over and it cheapens the creepy elements.
Still has the same problem from last time where not having a barrier towards the player means the courses that start uphill will waste your whole attempt because the balls rolls out of bounds.
Standing in fish seems to drive my guy mad with stress.

My brain will never get used to countering electricity with ice and water with electricity.

The UI for the elements should be arranged like the QWE-ASD keys imo, stacked on top of each other instead of in a line. 
Unless I'm mistaken, the barrier spell's calculations does not consider current elemental afflictions. So if you're wet and use fire on yourself the barrier breaks leaving you wet because it thinks you are going to be set on fire. 
Sometimes the melee bots gets confused and stand around, probably happens if their infighting target dies. 
There's one particular room which is a narrow rectangular box with a stripe of traps in the middle that on the third floor spawns an ungodly amount of turrets, completely packed. It killed a run and almost killed this one. Also the super narrow new one with the exploding bots is a nasty one if you stand to close to where they respawn without noticing.
Glad to see that the chasms don't kill you anymore it was a very silly way to lose a run. 

I love the new elemental look to the various rooms. The rooms look much more varied now.
The cauldrons are a good idea to allow for spell progression. Between them and the challenges it's starting to feel like playstyles differ more between playthroughs. Although it does cause some "wait do I have that in this run?" moments. I know that there's an icon on the bottom left but it's not exactly immediate. 
I think volatile tar used to be harder to make, now it's much easier to use and combo with fire. 
The challenge rooms are a nice addition but I only manages to do the water and ice ones, the fire one explodes me instantly.
The abyss summoner ability is really good because it zones enemies out and you can time your shot to spawn new one by getting the last hit on enemies inside the whirlpool. It's also really good on the fire boss variant because you can kill its summons in one hit and spawn a bunch of vortexes around it. Also it triggers on steam kills but I think that's intentional. My favorite new thing.

Anyways, good progress, had fun. 

Out of curiosity, do you remember if the tiles used to play WAX were bought in the shop or duplicated with a rune?

I can't remember, sorry.

Scatterbrained feedback:

I didn't realize that discarding passed a turn.

The rules for placing down multiple words in a single turn is unclear. Unless I'm misinterpreting what the bounties are asking me.

The tutorial doesn't need to be so verbose imo, people can figure out what each shop tab does by themselves.
Look at this SWEET "Yacht"

An in-game word validator would go a long way. I grabbed the letters needed to make "Chibi" but it's not valid. 
Also "virality" isn't valid?

What's wrong with "Wax" here?

Show tiles could be toggled by pressing alt or another key. Hotkeys in general would be nice. 
If you have an extra tile and discard one tile it wastes your turn since you don't get that extra tile back.
Music is kinda intense for a relaxing scrabble-like game but it's not bad. I like that it gets more intense as you play turns.

I grabbed Wuthering Heights and won by mistake after putting down "Ovum". I say by mistake because I was waiting for my last C to make "knock". Before that I had the usual scramble moment of waiting for the one vowel you need for a bunch of turns only to get two of them in a row (It was a U for "Quiz") but it's nowhere near as painful because you don't have competition blocking the board and stealing your letters.
Yeah, this game is gripping. The tutorial was a bit annoying but it is a more fun and more strategic version of scrabble. Very fun.

Early build so not too much to say. Please add some basic options for general volume and FPS limiting next time.

Seems a little clunky to individually control crewmen I don't see why the player would need to play anyone other than the commander. 
Having to use the cursor is an unnecessary extra step every time you want to take an action. A "look at a prompt and press the use button" system would be much smoother.

Looking forward to seeing how a proper mission plays. 

Just got done watching this, thanks for the video it's very useful.

I can see I did a poor job of communicating some important things and maybe that's why some people are finding it harder than others. I'll make sure gun pickups and supply crates are more noticeable. Rags tells you that the chieftain's camp is the harder of the two available levels but In retrospect it's obvious that if I unlock two levels at once they should be equally challenging, or at least I should add some difficulty indicator on the map screen. 

In my game's defense I think playing it with a timer trying to rush to the boss is counterproductive since a lot of resources are rewards for exploring but I agree that at the very least pistol and shotgun ammo should always be plentiful. I'll be more careful with balance going forward. 

Thanks again for streaming my game! It'll be more fun next time.

Thanks for playing and for the feedback!

I realize these are probably the first few levels but I found the game pretty easy even without the lifesteal upgrades (which made several parts trivial)

Balance is going to be a challenge. Some people tell me the game is too hard and other tell me the game is too easy apart from the bossfights. I think it comes down to experience with FPS games and using mutations well. Either way I think it's better if the game starts a bit too easy and gets challenging later on. 

I like Rag conceptually but wish he had a bit more personality

Noted, poor Rags was made in a day so he didn't have a ton of care put into him. He's meant to be a sidekick of sorts because I didn't want the player to feel like they're just a henchman, I might make the crew larger down the line if I want different characters for different roles.

some textures clash with eachother and the game overall looks a bit washed out to me. I honestly dont mind but it could put some people off

This will also be a challenge. I'm learning texturing as I go so some textures are different because I'm experimenting with things. I'll be sure to settle on a style and standardize existing textures before I can start churning out content. 

but the boat still doesnt feel very tied in with the main gameplay

Yeah, it's a level design issue, redoing the first level to be more boat-centric will be a priority. I could ditch the boat entirely for some levels though so the player doesn't have to go back for the boat after finishing them.

I think its neat. I would buy this game on Steam.

I am planning to put this on steam when I'm done so I'll do my best.
Thanks again for the comment, much appreciated!

Thanks for playing again, good to hear that the game has improved in some areas. 

I like the skybox but they’re very high res compared to everything else and clash as a result

I don't think it matters too much if the sky looks better than the rest of the game but I will be experimenting with lower res ones, especially because the ones I'm using are free assets and there's only so many different skyboxes I can make with those. 

but it’s really annoying that turning the boat doesn’t cause you to turn while standing on it

That sounds like it could be disorienting but I suppose I can test it out and see if it works.

You can walk right up to the boat but can’t jump high enough to actually get into it.

Noted, I'll make jumps from shallow water higher, that should do it.

For some reason when I got close to the shore the game’s framerate nosedived and the main thread started rocketing at max speed

Dang it. This happened to me a couple of times but I thought I had fixed it. It's something to do with the boat colliding with the shore at some specific angle, now I suspect it might be because of Godot's axis lock setting, if that's the case it should be an easy fix.
Sorry about that.

Thanks again for the feedback, it seems like I still need to iron out some kinks in visuals and gameplay before I can focus on adding content, but I think I'm getting close. 

Hey, thanks for playing and thanks for the feedback.

Too much grenades thrown at his second phase, his ground pound shouldn't be that powerful I think

I think a bigger arena with an extra row of columns will be enough to make him a more fair fight, also I need to find a way to teach players that "ground slam" type attacks can be avoided by jumping.

but normal shielded enemies were almost immune to the explosions

Unless something is broken they take two nades, which yeah I'll bump it down to one.

I didn't like the animations for human enemies too, they're very basic

They're the first enemies I made so it's good to hear I've gotten better. I'll make a note to redo their animations.

Pickups are very bright which on one hand makes them easier to find, but they also stand out from the surroundings a lot.

I've gotten some feedback about that, but I like having something that I can use to guide the player's eye towards secrets or the way forward. I guess they are a bit jarring. I'll have to think of a substitute if I do end up making them more plain.

Regarding lore

I didn't want to explain too much for the demo, I was thinking of adding an intro level down the line that would explain things more clearly.
Basically the idea is that, while rapid mutations caused the collapsed of modern society, by the time the game takes place contamination can be treated and most of the danger is from the mutated creatures themselves. Mutagenic serum is not the same as the industrial contaminant, it's meant to be stable and controllable so people can use it to give themselves useful genetic mutations. I understand that this might be counter intuitive, there's a chance that I might scrap the mutation system in favor of various equipment that does the same thing. 

And since people devolved why they managed to form tribes and even cooperate with other animals?

The tribe you fight are more like dumber aggressive humans than feral beasts. They are capable of having language, a social structure and even domesticating animals. Lore-wise the big fishmen enemies should be fighting with the tribals in the chieftain level but I didn't get infighting ready in time for the demo. Speaking of domestication, there's a pup that you can adopt in the lair level, it's right before the bossfight. Rags has unique dialogue if you bring it back before doing the chieftain level.

As a linear game it might not be as fun and replayable.

I did toy with some procedural generation but I found that it cheapens the exploration and it's a pain in the ass to set up. I'm definitely going to add more things to find in levels, and the mutation system could use some more depth yeah.
I just don't think this game can be anything more than a linear game, I'm hoping that a complete mutation system will give player different enough playstyles that replaying levels with different ones will be fun.

Anyway thanks again for the comment, much appreciated!

Short demo but flying around is fun. Some feedback:

I'd find it easier to fly if the camera was first person or if it rolled with the plane.
I thought it was lame how the plane wasn't affected by gravity and could stand still mid-air indefinitely but once I had to avoid missiles and get behind shields that control came in handy. 
I did kill the core by hovering next to it and spamming missiles though. 
The guns felt underpowered considering that you need to aim them and keep on target while you fire.

What's there is promising, I'm looking forward to playing this again.

Look at this CLEAN breakout:

This game feels like you're playing as a SWAT tank team the way you're slicing pies, like doorkickers but tanks.
It's a bit weird because peeking around corners in a way that doesn't expose you too much takes a lot of finesse with the commands but once combat starts if you're in a good position you just need to sit there and watch as the enemy vehicles funnel themselves in a killzone one after the other. If you turn the corner and there's too many enemies you pop smoke, fall back and wait, if you think you're lose you fire rockets. It plays well so far but I'm wondering how much variety there will be if all engagements can be resolved by baiting an enemy push into a firing squad of tanks.

For the loadout system I moved the big tank's optics to the second "Turret F" slot and used the freed slots to equip more rockets which I used liberally. 
idk if you can see it here but modules are being placed over eachother might have something to do with me swapping the k-50 for another k-75:

I can move modules and place them around but they leave a "fake" module in the background that I cannot click and I can place other modules on top of, those two "R8" modules are the same module and that "3R8" module is actually loaded on the k-75.

Infantry: their current implementation works fine as enemies but I couldn't get much use out of them. If they're caught by an enemy tank they are basically dead. My instincts was to use them as recon and have them spot enemies while hiding but buildings don't seem to give them a camouflage or cover bonus so if an enemy gets LoS they get vaporized.

Anyways, fun demo.

For the starting dialogue skip should complete the sentence first instead of skipping it right away. 

First run I got to the area with the conveyor belt thinking I would save there before starting but I got instantly killed by a jumpscare and it sent me back to the beginning. I think putting players in charge of saving the game and having that save cost limited resources is a recipe for frustration.
Second run got ended by an uphill + V-shaped barrier shot that I couldn't do. Uphill shots like that are much harder because the ball rolls back down and out of bounds which immediately fails your current try, if there were a barrier or the ball got reset to the starting position you could at least practice the shot 2 more times before starting your next try.
Last run I was doing the corner thing and I didn't realize an enemy had spawn and it killed me. I did hear the thing open but I thought it was another load of fish. Enemies could use some sound when attacking.

Last time I played this it had a putt button. I suppose holding down a single button is more elegant and less random but it is counter intuitive.
The camera smoothing is nauseating so I disabled it immediately but also the way the character moves feels bad to control, it's like you're dragging something heavy on ice. 
Bullet decals apply to the ball and the coins.

It took me a while to realize that I can reload a partly empty shotgun by pressing right click and that the lever on the shotgun indicates how many shots are left. 

Got to the jumpscare guy again, I realize now that it's a roaming monster and not something that's meant to kill you as you go save, which is a problem because I didn't save (didn't have money) and I got cornered.
I understand that you're trying to make the game more tense but I don't think this resource management system is doing it any favors. Spooky monsters would be enough imo.
Also causes some randomness problems because those courses with the barriers you have to shoot to raise are an ammo sink.
In some courses the ball can get wedged between an obstacle and the course's edge and it's hard to get an angle to hit it.

I still think the golfing is really fun. 

In the one room you can enter you slide against the right wall but not the left wall, this happened in my game because it was a convex polygon collision imported form blender without backface collision allowed

Thanks for playing and thanks for the feedback!

I tried being in the air while it performed it, didn't help

It should but maybe it's not working as intended. I'll check it out.

Why is there a distinction between available and consumed mutagens? Why would I want to not consume them?

It's a holdover from when there was a trading system and items could be bought and sold. I'll cut that.

most of my kills were from just circling the structure and using the mounted gun and the harpoon

That's intended, to a degree. I'm all for players cheesing a couple of enemy kills, if I want to force them to engage with an encounter from up close I can make enemies spawn or aggro through trigger areas. 

The chieftain fight was underwhelming. those health upgrades made things so much easier

Balance is in an horrid state right now, getting the right upgrades makes the game so much easier. The health on melee hit is so strong you can outheal a lot of encounters by standing still and swinging your machete. The chieftain's health was nerfed a bit because some players were having trouble with him, it's too easy to burst down as a result. It's the lesser of the two evils, the arena is too small and it's hard to avoid damage if he lets off a grenade + SMG combo. I guess he's due for a rework as well. I'm focusing on getting combat and movement feeling right so that's more important than trying to make it properly balanced for now, I will probably have to scrap at least the first two levels at some point anyway. A lot of people pointed out that the boat is not used enough and I agree, I was focusing on nailing down regular combat first so I made those levels as a series of land combat arenas and that isn't good enough. Given, not every level will have ample space for sailing but the first one sure should.

Thanks again for the notes! Much appreciated.

Not much to say since this is old levels.
I just now noticed that the Itch.io gifs show enemies flashing red when hit but that doesn't happen in game. I assume it's something you've removed? I think it looks nice.

Even with the framerate limit of 144 my game was running at 2500+ FPS until I enabled v-sync.
This also happens in-game but it goes down to 400 FPS.

This pier is wrong:

this is a trial run of the actual demo I’ll be putting up on Steam next week.

Best of luck!