Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

The accusation of being closed-minded and repetitious is subjective and lacks evidence. Instead of dismissing me as closed-minded, it's more constructive to address specific points of disagreement so we can seek common ground which I'm happy to do now, regardless of what I believe. 

Accusing me of projecting insecurities is a serious allegation. It's essential to provide concrete examples or evidence to support such claims rather than making blanket statements. 

If there's a genuine misunderstanding of each other's arguments, it's crucial we clarify and ensure mutual understanding rather than assuming the other party is intentionally misrepresenting viewpoints, which I claimed you may have done and apologize for that. 

Making assumptions about my religious beliefs without evidence is unfair and unproductive. It's best we focus on the substance of the discussion rather than making personal attacks.

The classification of "High School DxD" as shonen or seinen can be subjective and may vary depending on interpretation. Instead of asserting one's own classification as absolute truth, it's more productive we discuss the characteristics of the show and how they align with different demographic categories and this I understand now. 

If you feel the conversation is unproductive or frustrating, it's acceptable to disengage and I will politely do so as well.

(1 edit) (+1)

The classification of High School DxD as shounen is the official classification as stated by the original japanese publisher, you can verify it on any animes website, there is nothing subjective nor interpreted about it, this is not my personal classification, this is the official classification as stated by the original japanese publisher.

This is an anime about sex and yet nothing sexual ever actually happens even though the protagonist is a pervert surrounded by willing naked girls specifically because it was designed as a shounen meaning for kids and not for adults, hence why it does nothing but tease and blue-ball and why a fan-made adult version to relieve the frustration that it causes is needed, a fan-made adult version would not be needed if the original was designed for adults to begin with, hence here we are.

This is the difference between ecchi which are suggestive shounen and shoujo but don't contain any actual sexual content because they are destined to non-adult demographics and hentai which are actual porn seinen and josei destined to adult demographics.

Here are the official classifications as stated by japanese publishers:

shounen = for boys = non-adult male demographic

shoujo = for girls = non-adult female demographic

seinen = for men = adult male demographic

josei = for women = adult female demographic

Here are further explanations: https://epicstream.com/article/anime-genres-explained-from-shonen-to-seinen-shou...

A relatively reliable way to figure out the demographic target of an anime is their protagonists' demographics as their protagonists usually represent their demographic target.

Indeed, shounen usually center around a boy while shoujo usually center around a girl while seinen usually center around a man and josei usually center around a woman.

Hyoudou Issei, High School DxD's protagonist, is a teenager boy, not an adult man, because High School DxD was designed as a shounen implying that it was destined to teenagers boys, not adults, which is why it is suggestive while not featuring any actual sexual content because it was made for kids and which is why a fan-made adult version is needed to relieve frustration after so much teasing and blue-balling denying what adults want.

(+1)

I acknowledge your explanation, and understand the official classifications provided by Japanese publishers. I emphasize with your point that the protagonist's demographic aligns with the intended audience of the anime. The need for a fan-made adult version due to the teasing nature of the original for adult viewers. I appreciate the detailed breakdown provided in your message.