Post by fae.exe in Cursed! (Prototype) comments

Viewing post in Cursed! (Prototype) comments

I'm just wondering if skills ignoring 4s and just 25% chance of a failure per dice might not be a little too generous? With a skill of 1 you're going to have 74% chance of clean success, which raises the skill immediately, and then your chance of clean success is 94% with a skill of 2..!

And even if the DM is adding 2d4 every roll, you get 52% of clean success at skill level 1, and only 16% chance to make any cauldron dice back as the DM! At skill level 0 with 6d4, you still have the 52% chance of success, but only 18% chance of a clean success so there's that! But I'm not sure of the overall experience that those distributions are going to yield!

I think if I try it I'll see how it feels at first but my first design pass on this would be to really iterate on the ebb and flow of the cauldron and the DM moves tied to that, maybe really go full DM-moves list a la PbtA?

Mean Green Press64 days ago(+1)

Oooh yeah you're absolutely right, I think I pulled my punches with that resolution mechanic (and this certainly isn't the concept for me to be doing that 😅). I had an early version of it that was wayyyy too harsh, but I must have overcorrected and made it more forgiving than I wanted. Live and learn, but now that the jam is over I have all the time in the world to fiddle with it!

And going PBTA/borrowing some ideas is soooo tempting. I absolutely love PBTA and how those systems inject narrative beats into the game. I think those design principles would work well here, especially for The Cauldron like you said. DM moves as a concept were probably floating around in my brain somewhere when I started The Cauldron, but ty for helping me make that connection! I really appreciate you taking the time to give your feedback on this, I'll definitely be using it when I salvage this for a more concrete version someday 💚

itch.io

Viewing post in Cursed! (Prototype) comments