IDC how horny you are, Agnes is still a rapist and I hate her. (Btw Elena wasn't in the list but she would go in "meh")
By that same logic, Annie has to go as well then, no? The first sexual scene of the game that wasn't a dream? I haven't been under the impression that any advances made by any of the female characters have been unwelcomed by the MC. Nor has any legitimate harm come to the MC or the rest of the cast of characters. No need for a rewrite, just additional details as Hatchet said.