You were browsing the popular section. What is to be popular is not decided by your taste. Not even by good ratings. It is decided by an algorithm that ranks games based on several things, including recent popularity. Judging by the comments, lots of people visit that ginger game, coming from youtube.
Look at https://itch.io/games/top-rated and https://itch.io/games/top-rated/last-30-days for a bit of quality ranking. And best combine with a tag of your nieche of interest, like rpg or rpg-maker.