I really liked the cutscenes and the artwork, they were really well done and gave the game a surreal horror vibe.
The sprites were okay, but I'd say the walking animations needed more work. Regarding the maps and tilesets, I'd say that they were okay but some rooms felt a bit empty (the graveyard and the church were pretty good though).
The story was quite interesting, as well as the characters, and I liked how the story unfolded. It had some horror clichés/tropes/stereotypes and I really like that (for example, the protagonist returning after a long time; the guy accused of killing his friends when in reality something paranormal took place that night, etc).
The music felt a bit too happy and kinda out of place. I personally think just environmental sounds would have worked better in the town section.
Overall, I think it was a fun game and I quite liked the story and the progression. It's a shame it ended so abruptly when things were getting really interesting, but nonetheless, great job!