@ Rising Wolf Games,
You have it in you to make great games. You really do. My advice would be to try and find your own way [or path] and stick less to the footsteps you're following atm.
I'm convinced you can come up with great stuff. For inspiration: watch Japanese horror movies. They are truly great at creating a very scary atmosphere, without too much blood and gore.
I'm following you, so whenever you add a new game, I'm onto it :o]
Best of luck [that's something you deserve too]!