Gameplay - I really want to rate this higher, but it's just too messy. I couldn't even finish because I couldn't figure out how to get out of the throne room with the ring and emerald, and it's hard to justify continuing to look for a solution when there's a door on the left that just doesn't work and I can't decide if the puzzle is even possible or not. 1
Story - There's barely anything, just a basic premise. 1
Presentation - I think the art style is great and I like the map style and design, even if it can be hard to tell where the path to other maps is. 3
Creativity - There's definitely something here, and the wine puzzle is creative. 3
Horror - There's very little horror besides the atmosphere and the shadow butterfly that's extremely easy to avoid. 2
Theme - There are plenty of jewels but none of theme are explicitly cursed as far as I could find. There are curses though at least. 2
If this game is updated to fix the various issues (and perhaps just include a quick guide like Three Yellow Quartzes so people can more easily identify if they're stuck because they could't solve the puzzle or stuck because the game broke) I will absolutely play it again, but as is I can't spend any more time on it.