So I played again. This time I reversed things and told her she wasn't allowed to leave. She kept insisting she be allowed to go out. Then we did some house chores and I said I was going to sleep and she opened the door on her own.
The next time I played, I immediately said she was being rude and that she should just go. She asked if we could talk about it but I said there was nothing to talk about. She agreed to leave and said she was going to give me the exit key.
