Thank you so much for replying with help! Where I'm at now, You notes that there's something in the well they can't just jump in to find, the rope in the farmer's house is out of reach, there's nothing else in the barn, re-reads the church sermon, and says that they need more clues for the monolith. I've been thinking that there must be a way to find something to climb on or cut the rope down to use it and get into the well, or that there might be a way to reach the upper level by the waterfall to find something not yet interacted with, but in those five areas I can't seem to find any more interactions. Or I might have done the order wrong at some point during my exploration. (I did also find the book about lucid dreaming, if that's one of the sequence triggers.) Thank you so much for sharing tips/advice on how to progress, I really appreciate it. :)
Thanks for replying again! Yeah, it's so strange. I've looked through the desks and files in the station's top floor, along with the upstairs locked room in You's own house, but something still seems to be missing somewhere. (Lots of really fun and interesting inspection dialogue too! I'm excited to learn more about the things in those rooms, but I don't wanna spoil it for anyone else reading) I've also looked at the neighbor kid's house and the secret hideout, though I'm not sure how much they helped for solving the first dream.