My mistake. I played through it real quick and figured out enough to solve it. You need to put the correct items on each of the other pillars. I'll post the solution down below.
Leftmost pillar is Beer, you can get that from the tavern of the main town.
Second is Horehound. Thought it was the Herb of Grace for a while, which messed me up. Horehound can be found at the Goat Tribe.
Third is a Feather. Those can be found at Sundersilk Cascades.
Fourth is a Pokect Bell. You can get them by beating up some goats.
Last is Iron Ingot. Thought it was the small trowel for a while, so this one messed me up as well. This can be obtained by fighting werewolves in the dark forest.