This was as fun as Timberlodge! It was pretty spooky and well made! The actual sounds and environment was pretty scary and spooky! As well as the fear of something happening, was well done!
That being said, I did feel like there were a lot of down parts to the game; where I felt like the environment wasn't used fully to its potential as no actual scares of spooks happened with the character in any of the actual environments they walk around in.Also the killer taping everything and leaving it in the store was a bit of a stretch as there was no reason why they would do that (or that's how it felt to me). Also we don't get to know the character that we play more for the last decision to really make an emotional impact. The character is silent most of the time and doesn't say much other than what the player chooses.
As well as the 'Society being bad' part of the VHS wasn't really explored outside of the VHS', so that too didn't feel like it fit the story much.
Those of course are just my opinions and thoughts, others might feel different. I still thought that your game was really fun and was spooky! Good luck on future projects and hope to see more!