itch.io

It's been a little while but if I remember correctly you get the red one first, put it in the statue (your HR has to be level 3 I think to use the statue; increase your HR by doing quests at the tavern). After you put in the red one it should unlock a few other paths. If you hover over the rocks in the way of the path then it'll tell you the requirements. Click on the rock blocking the path and it should unlock. Once another path unlocks you should be able to get the blue one next, just follow the paths. After that, collect all the pages for the "booty wall", type in the code at the "booty wall" and it'll give you the yellow dildo. Hope this helps!