Open The Sails!: This is really fun to listen to! You have a great combination of driving drums, swelling and supportive bass under fast jig-like melody with non-intrusive countermelody. This definitely feels like a track that fits a sailing theme.
Lying low Under the Island Sun: Your use of the I-IV-I-V chord progression gives this track such a happy feel and the fun slightly swung bassline gives this an island vibe. Similar to the previous track, the B section feels mellow, which is a nice stylistic choice to give the ears a break from the A section so that it feels fresh on the loop.
Talk of the Town: You captured the tavern/pub feel well here. The mixolydian mode with the I-bVII vamp feels lively and also a little bit sly at the same time.
Barter and Bargain: I really like the delay on your melody. I think this is the first theme in which I happen to think your B section is the highlight of the piece! The space allowed in the bass while the melody and the xylophone dance together overtop feels like the bartering that you might hear at the village shop.
Cannons at the Ready: You have a lot of energy charged in this theme! It feels dark and fight-like musically with the driving rhythm section, but also with your use of the flat second scale degree to give it that slightly dark tint. I think this is my favorite theme of all your songs!
Keep Your Head!: So much tension! This carries an energy that also makes me ready for a fight, but in contrast to the previous piece, this one has an added anxiety to it that comes only with a 1 on 1 duel.
A Nobody Among the Wreckage: It was very creative of you to make a bad ending theme. This song is dark and brooding. Despite this though, I still hear the twinkle of the stars overhead as if maybe not all is lost… maybe? The ending may make me think otherwise… :)
Keeping Watch at Midnight: This ending also feels dark and brooding as well, possibly a fitting ending to the RPG adventure you imagine. The lore on your project page is hilarious and extremely well-written. Whichever one of you wrote it needs to write a book or something if you aren’t already an author! The music is also very well-written and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing!