I've never heard that happening to anyone before, could you post a video of it perhaps?
Viewing post in Mysteries Under Lake Ophelia comments
I was only able to replicate it once more after a couple minutes of trying but I didn't get the full clip. I was trying to get the full video but couldn't. Before the video started the reel and the fish came out of the water and floated towards the character right as it was about to come out the water and be caught. Now I am stuck.
Edit: I got it once more with a full clip this time.