Does anyone know how to get the toy from the guy in front of the shrine? the last one i need is the one he has but all i get when talking to him is him complaining about not having a boyfriend. any ideas?
You need to feed all the cats and dogs for the shrine maiden, but then choose to keep your wish for later. Then talk to the guy again and you'll get the option to use your wish to get him a boyfriend. If you've already used your wish, you're sadly out of luck... as I was my first few playthroughs. ;)