Charming! Was happy to see a PICO-8 entry into the jam.
Visual wise the game ended up very well - although some of the arrow inputs can get hard to understand with the floating effects, it isn't that hard to guess what they are once it get's going.
The story was fine, considering how much you added into it, but either I believe I ran into a few bugs were some of my choices didn't matter or were switched around (Like buying the Silver Sword and getting the Stake prompt at the end).
Anyhow, they are probably simple things to fix. Really happy for the choice of the engine. :D