Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
Tags

Just a general comment... I've followed this game through its development for quite a while, and I've most definitely noticed that it has gotten several drastic changes. It's to the point that it's not even particularly close to the game it used to be. These don't even really feel like updates so much as you just trying to figure out what sort of game you want to make. Obviously it hasn't even hit version 1.0 yet, so of course not everything is set in stone, but... it's over halfway to 1.0, and at the pace of changes that have been happening, I'm a bit concerned that the core game mechanics are still going to continue to change even after 1.0, which could alienate some people.

(+1)

It's how game productions go tbh. You iterate over your designs until you're happy with them.

I'm happy with the core mechanics now though. I wanna tweak how stamina works soon but that's the last thing in my list. After that there shouldn't be that many drastic changes to how the flow of combat and progression works.

Cheers.

(2 edits)

Maybe I just don't usually actually play games continuously throughout their early development, so I don't see the process. I think most of the time those decisions are made before any sort of public release. What I'm more used to is a developer going on hiatus because they didn't like the direction it was going, and taking time off to make a decision before releasing a single full overhaul.

(+2)

Hi Sombreve, as someone currently working in design you are absolutely correct. You continue iterating and gathering feedback to fix pain points and emphasise the game's unique features. You're doing great work. 

(2 edits) (-1)

Perhaps this is how it should be done, but if that is the case, then the vast majority of designers and game companies don't do it correctly.

From my perspective... the people who are following a game through its development probably don't want to suddenly be playing a different game, else they very likely wouldn't have been interested in the game initially. Like me, I enjoyed this game in previous iterations. I completely lost interest and actually uninstalled it for while. Reinstalled it later... played it a bit, but just... wasn't feeling it. Haven't even played the last two versions because the changelog just doesn't grab my interest at all. It's changing core mechanics that I had already grown accustomed to, and I don't want to play a completely different game than the one I initially downloaded and liked.

Perhaps I wouldn't notice and would still enjoy the game if I hadn't played the older versions, since I wouldn't have grown accustomed to them.

(+1)

Version numbering isn't the same as decimal places.

The versions can go on like this: 0.8 -> 0.9 -> 0.10 -> 0.11 -> 0.12 and so on.

For all we know, it could be less than 10% on it's way to 1.0