It is a win, because both are great games. I like WS over Bad memories not because BM is an inferior VN. If I was judging it purely based on traditional views Bad memories would win hands down. But I tend to judge based on how I react to them mentally. WS is a roller-coaster and very difficult to guess what is going to happen, Bad Memories is different where It's carefully crafted and you can kind of get a handle on where the story is going. Both are amazing games but the creative freedom you have when creating WS is refreshing, it's something that is greatly lacking today.