does anyone else think herbert might be the antagonist/villain?
To be honest, if Andy were to introduce a villain it would probably be best to be outside of the main group of characters
Big(?) Spoiler:
Out of everyone who was in the picture, I'd say Herbert would probably be the best contender for an antagonist role in the story with all the flashback and mystery surrounding him. And as previously stated in Mark's storyline, Walter's mom did say Herbert was going out of his room more setting up an appearance or even maybe a start to his antagonistic role? Or I might just be looking into things too much lol.
But I could clearly see a story without the antagonist element introduced.
Well talbot is a potential antagonist, but that can only be happen in Gil's route, and he can't be a villain.
There is a difference between the "antagonist" and a "villain"
Villains are antagonist that is hate by everyone, and he as a villain also hates every character, that is why the word "VILLAIN" is strong calling/naming.
In Talbot's case, everyone hates him, but walter is the only character (maybe) that Talbot want to deal with and one of the MC likes him (somehow) but he's consider as antagonist. (IF I SPOKE SOMETHING WRONG, YOU'RE FREE TO CORRECT)