Ah, I had no idea you had those tools for the sprites, that does help a lot. And using them has fixed the issue. It seems duplicating a current cosmetic and swapping the sprites isn't sufficient, I believe it has something to do with what you said about the naming. Either way, using the tool to slice the sprites and create the scriptable object has fixed the issue and everything works great. Thank you for messaging back even on your holiday time. Take it easy!