Sorry I've been remiss in keeping this updated...
2 more reviews:
Gameboomers - http://www.gameboomers.com/reviews/Cc/CaptainD/CaptainD.htm - they sort of liked it but it's not really the reviewers preferred style of game, enjoyed it because of (and despite) its silliness.
AdventureGamers - https://adventuregamers.com/articles/view/34350 - they liked aspects of it, but found other parts disappointing. Most of the criticisms were fair to be honest, but some felt a little harsh! (Anyway overall they enjoyed it which is the main thing.)