personally I think both of you are wrong because both PT, RE/SH series manage to hit a huge mark for horror games in general there's no reason to compare RE and SH because besides being survival horror games they both are different personally I prefer SH over RE because SH focuses on truly disturbing and psychologically scaring the player while although RE is scary it just has more action than horror but overall all SH and RE both made a good part of horror video games and PT is a game that managed to actually remake the unnerving style perfectly that almost every aspect of horror that SH 1-4 created too bad the game got canceled and Konami are just gonna use it for money and at capcom have done a great job at making RE 7 and the remakes of 2-3
They did a "great job" at making the RE3 lazy cringey moviewannabe remake with removed content, censored gore, no puzzles, boss fights for little kids, removed enemies, generic characters redesign, cringey quotes, stupid moments, RE5-6 style gameplay for little kids, they did a "great job"? lol nice joke dude, i'm sorry but i can't take your answer seriously after what you said, Capcom didn't do a "great job" at all, all of those games have almost nothing of Resident Evil and even if we look at all aspects of them without thinking about that they are still mediocre lazy games, oh and P.T did nothing, it was a boring playable teaser walking simulator that had nothing of Silent Hill, i'm actually glad that it got cancelled, a Silent Hill moviewannabe game with just graphics and Norman Reedus would be trash :D :P