Pros and cons are down below) Check out my vid here (likes and subs are highly and highly appreciated)):
Advantages:
1. I liked the story a lot even though it has some holes in the plot (the 2d point in the disadvantages section). I think it was pretty cool that there were several chapters and locations to explore.
2. I liked that it was pretty logical where to go at all times. The player was either led forward by the lights or the gates. Really enjoyed that.
3. I think the witch was pretty scary. She had some nice dance moves as well) Great job creating a scary-looking monster! I got scared a couple of times especially when I didn't expect her to come at me (near the end of the game that happened).
Disadvantages:
1. What are the villagers doing? Before the disappearance, they are at least seem to be picking flowers and at the end of the game, their actions make no sense at all. Kind of weird.
2. The person who stole the rock left the note before the witch killed them and before the disappearance. How could they know about the disappearance? And if they knew, why couldn't they bring the stone back themselves? And why is the main character - the only one to survive the witch and the only one that hasn't disappeared. I feel like the story could have been a bit smoother. And if they knew that everybody has disappeared, why would they leave a note in the first place?
Overall:
I think the game was pretty cool. The plot was the main advantage of the game but it still had some holes (or the story just didn't explain some moments) so I rate the game 4/5 stars. I feel that there's still room for further development but it was a pretty good game nonetheless!
Hope my feedback was useful!