Wow, thanks for the speedy reply! I tried both combinations for the present several times, but it still doesn't seem to be working for me. Should I try changing my outfit to something fancier?
That's odd.. I have the game's code open right now and that should be the solution!
Is there a chance you already unlocked her card and you just need to speak with her?
I don't think so, she just says the same thing every time, and the checkmark isn't in snail's book yet