Btw amazing game! This is the first point and click game I have ever found myself enjoying, it is so refreshing to play and had me on the edge start to finish!
Thank you, I'm really glad you enjoyed it! If you need one of the top candles, they are from the new prequel story, you need to beat the nightmare to have it. Once you have that ending, check the blood hole in the main game, and after you do that, try to do the a new life ending one more time, you'll know what to do. :)