Pros and cons are down below) Check out the gameplay here (the game is the 3d there):
Advantages:
1. I absolutely love the concept. There are so many differnet endings and ways to go through the game. Makes the player want to know more and try again and again. I love how well though the consequences are!
2. The game is atmospheric! It reminded me a bit of the film Lighthouse (which is expectable cuz the game takes place in a lighthouse).
3. The weird noises are so unsettling! I loved them. I didn't get why the oven was so chatty and what it wanted from me but them whispers freaked me out!
Disadvantages:
1. The endings are a bit bland. I guess some nice sound cues would improve the situation a lot. The sound of a raven woman sreaming or seagals squeeking (or whatevet they do) would be nice to add, for example.
2. The whole concept of kiling a seabird being a bad omen needs to be underlined. Maybe it would be cool to make this sentence appear before the game starts after the player presses "play". Because for me the game was cool but after I paid attention to the title (at the very end of my playthrough), it made so much more sense suddenly.
Overall:
The game is cool, add a bit more vibrant endings and the experience will be perfect. Still, I believe the hard work deserves appreciation and the game deserves a 5-star rating.
Hope my feedback was useful!