This was... a good idea. I like the idea of hunting for the treasure and following clues. The answers from each sailor is funny and shows that some work went into it. There were some issues tho.
(rot13) bx fb Yngvghqvany gb n ebpx naq Ybatvghqvany gb n oneery, abg gung pybfr gb gur pbnfg, abg gung pybfr gb gerrf. Gur bayl barf jub gryy gur gehgu ner gur cneebg naq gur zreznvq.